Benicio Del Toro (21 Grams)
In the tightest overall race in these awards, Benicio Del Toro came
away with the Best Supporting Actor trophy for his performance in 21
Grams, beating out two different pairs of actors. Any one of the top
five could have taken this prize easily had votes swung a little.
This is Del Toro's second win from this bunch; we gave him the same
award for Traffic back in 2000 in the ancestor of the Calvins.
Fenster continues to look like one of the greatest actors of his
generation and I would guess that the De Niro or Pacino mantle is his
for the taking, if he wants it. His intense yet principled ex-con was
the catalyst for everything in the film and that he held the film
together despite its seemingly random narrative shifts says a lot
about his performance.
Second place went to Sean Astin as Samwise Gamgee in The Return of
the King, making his first major impression on this crew in the three
films. Playing a gay character is always a good way to... wait, you
mean he wasn't gay? My mistake. Astin was the emotional rock of the
last film of this trilogy, and was a supporting actor in the true
sense of the word.
Third and fourth place went to two actors from Mystic River, Tim
Robbins and Kevin Bacon. Robbins had the flashier role, playing the
emotionally damaged Dave Boyle, seemingly incapable of recovering
from childhood trauma. Bacon's rather subdued work had tended to get
ignored when people talked about the film but not here; our voters
were able to pick out what a crucial role he had to play in the
relationship of old friends torn apart.
Fifth place went to Andy Serkis, who suffered from a bit of "been
there, seen that" in regards to his groundbreaking work as Gollum in
Return of the King after finishing second last year. In addition,
that tricksy fat hobbit named Samwise stole his thunder as the acting
performance to buzz over in King. Poor, poor Gollum.
Newcomer Ken Watanabe took sixth place for his role in The Last
Samurai, mostly for stealing the film away from Mr. Movie Star, Tom
Cruise. Watanabe was Last Samurai's only recognition anywhere in the
Calvins, a big upset for a film with great potential.
Bobby Cannavale of the Station Agent and Paul Bettany from Master and
Commander tied for seventh (the latter benefiting from carryover votes
from Best Actor), matching (more or less) the results of the lead
actors in their films. Djimon Hounsou's dying artist from In America
and Geoffrey Rush's scenery chewing counter-part to Johnny Depp in
Pirates of the Caribbean round out the top ten to make a category that
really could have been anyone's. (Reagen Sulewski/BOP)
Top Ten
|
Position |
Actor |
Film |
Total Points |
1
|
Benicio Del Toro
|
21 Grams
|
55
|
2
|
Sean Astin
|
The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
|
52
|
3
|
Tim Robbins
|
Mystic River
|
48
|
4
|
Kevin Bacon
|
Mystic River
|
44
|
5
|
Andy Serkis
|
The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
|
42
|
6
|
Ken Watanabe
|
The Last Samurai
|
39
|
7 (tie)
|
Bobby Cannavale
|
The Station Agent
|
32
|
7 (tie)
|
Paul Bettany
|
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
|
32
|
9 (tie)
|
Djimon Hounsou
|
In America
|
29
|
9 (tie)
|
Geoffrey Rush
|
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
|
29
|
Best Picture
Best Director
Best Actor
Best Actress
Best Supporting Actor
Best Supporting Actress
Best Cast
Best Screenplay
Best Overlooked Film
Best Scene
Best Use of Music
Worst Picture
Worst Performance
Best Trailer
Best Breakthrough Performance
Best DVD
Best Special Effects
Return to the 2004 Calvin Awards